Group of people watching fireworks, at a celebration probably not marking 10 years of the Higher Education and Research Act.
Photo by Andrey_Larin from Freerange Stock

The last week or so the country has been full of celebratory gatherings, participants looking at firework displays with awestruck looks on their faces.  As someone who has worked in higher education for so long, it has been wonderful to see such public engagement with the celebrations for the ten year anniversary of the passage of Higher Education and Research Act.

Though the part of me that used to be a historian of seventeenth century England is metaphorically tugging at my sleeve to suggest that perhaps I’m getting confused and overlooking another historical event that’s marked at this time of year.

Nevertheless we’re now a decade into the brave new world for the English higher education; and the dystopian quality of this is a perspective shared by many, both in the sector and among the wider public.

brave new world

One of the consequences of HERA was to be a more agile, dynamic and diverse sector, as innovative new providers entered while older, ‘lower quality’ providers were ushered towards the door marked ‘market exit’.  This new sector, of course, had its roots in the funding and student number control revolution earlier in the 2010s, and the development of new ‘higher education providers’ was given significant press attention in the Cameron era.  One of these new providers was the New College for the Humanities (NCH), founded in 2011 to great fanfare (and since 2019 the London outpost of Northeastern University).  In a manner that was very out of character, the UK media reported the establishment of NCH in a rather breathless way; indeed, NCH was to be a new Oxford or Cambridge.

As this was happening, Sir David Watson was, as ever, a calm port in the storm of commentary.  When approached for comment Watson pointed out the need for perspective.  Crucially, he said, in higher education if you wanted to understand what was going on you needed to follow the award, not follow the money.  And if this advice was followed it was clear that NCH was just one more addition to the lengthy list of institutions offering validated awards from a university.  NCH was an interesting new addition, but not a revolutionary one.

I can’t now locate the article where Watson said this, but that I didn’t hallucinate this (I’ll leave that to LLMs) is, I’d argue, confirmed by the fact he returned to the “’follow the award’ rather than “follow the money”’ advice in his 2014 HEPI Pamphlet Only Connect.

we’re not in Kansas anymore

‘Follow the award not the money’ is a phrase worth reflecting on at this point in English higher education’s current trials.  It still remains good advice in many ways, and as a recovering QA manager and a current QA reviewer it is advice to which I’m quite partial.

However, the higher education world is very different now, compared to the 2010s when the phrase was coined.  As the sector’s previous business model has been increasingly undermined over the last decade, the distinction between ‘follow the award’ and ‘follow the money’ has blurred.  Not so much to be indistinguishable, but to an extent we wouldn’t have imagined in the early 2010s.

For many universities unable to raise their international student numbers sufficiently to address the domestic funding shortfall (in both education and research), utilising degree awarding powers has been the means to bridge that gap.  Domestic franchising and validation arrangements.  International partnerships and campuses.  Rapid expansions in both that have blurred the ‘follow award/money’ distinction, so that they’re still distinct but the overlap between the two has grown ever larger.  And given the current rush of UK universities to establish TNE partnerships as they seek to diversify and increase their income, it seems that this will continue.  Following the award is increasingly following the money.

Which brings me to OfS and its approach to regulating quality.

playing catch-up

As partnership provision expands at an accelerating rate, and increasingly the award becomes the money in terms of institutional financial sustainability, the importance of effective regulation of academic quality and standards becomes ever more crucial.

Higher education programmes delivered through domestic and international partnerships can, and usually are, very effectively managed and governed by the universities that are the awarding bodies for these degrees.  However, the recent problems with domestic franchised provision offered by a small number of universities have shown that this is not always the case.  This has led to both a new OfS registration condition covering this provision, and the much clearer responsibility of awarding bodies for such provision that has been built into OfS’s new quality/TEF proposals.

There is, though, no attention to or coverage of TNE leading to awards by English universities.  This is currently explicitly out of scope of the new registration condition and approach to regulating quality, and the timing for it being brought into the scope of the latter is unclear.

For this to be the case for a regulator now eight years old is, seen from one perspective, unconscionable neglect. And it is made far worse by the current rate of expansion in TNE by English universities, making it an ever more important issue.  There is, though, another perspective and one which appeals to (perhaps the more idealistic) part of me.

living up to responsibilities

As noted, it is perfectly possible to manage the academic quality and standards of TNE in a robust way, that assures the degrees offered and offers students a high-quality academic experience.  Indeed English universities do this and have been doing for some time now, previously under oversight from QAA and now despite the almost total lack of this from OfS.

This blindspot in the OfS approach is an opportunity.  As English universities significantly expand their TNE provision, they can (and should) do so in ways and with a rigour that demonstrate across the board their commitment to, and effectiveness in, assuring robust quality and standards.  And by doing so, demonstrate that achieving this does not need heavy-handed external regulation.

As a sector English universities have already fluffed a similar opportunity.  As domestic partnership provision expanded rapidly from the late 2010s, the vast majority of English universities were more than equal to this responsibility.  They, and the sector as a whole, were let down by the weaker members of the brethren who failed to manage their domestic partnerships effectively.  All universities in the English sector now need to prove that they have learned the lessons of this, and demonstrate that collectively we merit the autonomy and responsibility which we always cite in the face of calls for increased regulation.

And is particularly important as I’m not sure OfS has the capability to regulate the academic quality and standards of TNE.

the gap

Of course OfS claims to regulate TNE already, but as confirmed in an Insight Brief in 2023 this largely relies on self-reporting of reportable events by providers, and considering ‘notifications’ from staff, students and the public.  The core OfS quality processes such as they are (TEF; B3; the new integrated quality system) do not incorporate TNE.

A, if not the, reason for this is the data does not exist to allow OfS to do this, and OfS is working with Jisc to develop the data collected (the Aggregate Offshore Return – AOR) in a way that will support regulation.  While developing the AOR is probably a good thing, no matter how much data the OfS collects it is difficult to see how the regulator’s outcome-based approach to regulating academic quality and standards can be extended to TNE.

Even if comprehensive and valid data (NSS; continuation; completion; progression) is collected, that data needs to be interpreted; thresholds and benchmarks need to be established.  And these cannot simply be an imposition of the thresholds and benchmarks that are used for provision delivered in England.  They need to take account of the national economic, social and cultural contexts in which TNE programmes are delivered and student outcomes are achieved.  This feels like a Sisyphian task, perhaps impossible given the different ways in, and extent to, which the essential contextual data is collected and made available in each of the countries in which English universities offer TNE.

Of course in some respects I’m no impartial observer, as I think OfS’s current approach to quality regulation within England is fundamentally flawed and so extending that to TNE would be similarly unsound.  But even if that were a good idea (and it’s not), I’m not convinced that its possible or practicable.

where now?

So how would that leave the regulation of academic quality and standards for TNE? What would work? How about this …

A form of co-regulation that recognises that while scrutiny of outcomes data by the regulator can play a role, it is unlikely to be able to do so in the way it does in England; accepting the increased importance that this will place on effective institutional processes for assuring the academic quality and standards of TNE provision; and taking account of both of these, building an external regulatory approach that pays attention to those institutional processes for assurance.

Will that happen?  I don’t believe in miracles.

Leave a Reply

Previous: